ADHD Open Space
ADHD Open Space Podcast
ADHD PKM Showdown: Notion vs. Obsidian, which is better for neurospicy brains?
0:00
-53:07

ADHD PKM Showdown: Notion vs. Obsidian, which is better for neurospicy brains?

I bet you can guess the answer: it depends.
Transcript

No transcript...

Outline for this podcast (transcription coming soon)

Notion

Pros

  • market leader

  • Lots of tutorials

  • Lots of templates, free and purchasable

  • Databases, not just documents

  • Customization options (kind of)

  • handles lots of media

  • Has lots of integrations (pricey)

  • Web-based, so stays synced.

  • for ADHD:

    • Can be colorful

    • Can integrate timers/widgets

    • Can use same data in different views < — this is ultimately why it’s better for ADHD

    • Lots of professional ADHD coaches or other professionals say it’s the best thing for them, and so there is a community of NotionADHD folks (is there?)

  • Being professionally developed, so keeps getting better all the time (usually with things people have been asking for

  • Pretty helpful AI

  • Apple widgets

Cons

  • No offline access

  • iPad app is frustratingly different (no pencil integration)

  • IOS app is better, but if you plan on using that you’re going to want to configure your workspace

  • Lack of security

  • Lack of buy-in from coworkers, etc.

  • Delay lets you get distracted easily

  • Lots of rabbit holes trying to make things pretty/more efficient

  • Easy to be overwhelmed.

  • Costs money, though there are nonprofit rates and AI is cheap

  • Sort of markdown, but really proprietary

  • No ability to sketch within the app.

  • iPad pen scribble only work haphazardly.

Resources

  • Caren Magill

  • Notion mastery

  • The Notion Bar

  • By Regina.com

  • Consumer 2 Creator Lab

  • The wish they worked for me list:

    • Life OS

    • Bulletproof workspace

Obsidian:

Pros:

  • Fast and simple and non-proprietary

  • customize entire workspace

  • Community for themes & plugins

  • Graph view is cool

  • iPadOS versions work pretty much the same.

  • Quick to launch, easy to write in

  • Daily note! Built in!

  • Endlessly interesting

  • Very active community

  • Honestly, it just feels fun. You feel like you’re a bit more of a hacker.

  • Very cool backstory

  • Can (sort of) draw on iPad with excalidraw

Cons:

  • Great for note taking & note linking, but for database stuff and task/project management requires plugins/complex syntax/learning curve.

  • Costs money to sync easily (not terrible, but it’s real).

  • Endless customization makes it a Sarlacc Pit

  • Not as friendly to multiple file types as Notion (at least, not out of the box)

  • Still no built-in sketch or diagram capacity.

  • Graph view is cool, but ultimately not terribly useful (to me)

  • Not as many templates available, particularly not for ADHDers.

    • Except for a very thorough write up in the r/ObsidianMD channel on Reddit

Resources:

  • Linking Your Thinking (great community, great course)

  • Danny Hatcher

  • Bryan Jenks (adhd)

  • Nicole Van Der Hoeven

  • Ellane (on Medium.com)

  • Good example of what it takes (which, btw, I love and have to resist the temptation to try): https://www.arc.wtf/blog/pkm-madness/

0 Comments
ADHD Open Space
ADHD Open Space Podcast
The ADHD Open Space Podcast is for adult professionals living with ADHD and those who interact with them. We’ll talk about how it affects our work and those we care about.
As the “open space’ implies, there is room to explore more, so feel free to leave suggestions and comments for each episode!
The ADHD Open Space event will be January 20th, 2024 in Madison, WI. Registration opens December 1st at http://adhdopen.space!